• NEWS
    • NATION
    • CORDILLERA
  • BUSINESS
  • GREEN
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
  • FEATURE
  • FACT CHECK
  • HEALTH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • LITERATURE
  • SPORTS
  • ADVERTORIALS
  • ABOUT US
    • CONTACT US
Baguio Chronicle
  • NEWS
    • NATION
    • CORDILLERA
  • BUSINESS
  • GREEN
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
  • FEATURE
  • FACT CHECK
  • HEALTH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • LITERATURE
  • SPORTS
  • ADVERTORIALS
  • ABOUT US
    • CONTACT US
No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    • NATION
    • CORDILLERA
  • BUSINESS
  • GREEN
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
  • FEATURE
  • FACT CHECK
  • HEALTH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • LITERATURE
  • SPORTS
  • ADVERTORIALS
  • ABOUT US
    • CONTACT US
No Result
View All Result
Baguio Chronicle
No Result
View All Result
Home Fact Check

FACT CHECK: Igorots have tails #FactsFirstPH

Baguio Chronicle by Baguio Chronicle
November 28, 2022
in Fact Check
Reading Time: 7 mins read
FACT CHECK: Igorots have tails #FactsFirstPH
18
SHARES
68
VIEWS
Claim: Igorots have tails
Rating: FALSE
Facts: Put this under “Irritatingly False” but this is an example of one of the earliest fact-checks ever, which still has an enduring effect till now.
William Williams Keen Jr. is the first American brain surgeon and was a theistic evolutionist. In 1922, he authored the famous book “I Believe in God and in Evolution.”
It went through several editions and in 1925, Keen included a short chapter on “Human Beings with Tails” including a picture of an Igorot with what appeared to be a tail.
He wrote: The literature as to tails in human beings is extensive. Cases have been reported from every continent, and, including the United States, from almost every important nation in the world.
Virchow and Sir Arthur Keith, the distinguished Curator of the Hunterian Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons of England, London, than whom there can be no better authorities, and other well known writers, refer to cases of genuine tails. Some of them contain no bones, but others have rudimentary vertebrae, with complete joints between them. The microscope also shows in some cases sufficient muscular fibers to have made the tails capable of movement.
These tails are continuations of the lowest vertebrae. The ‘coccyx,’ the usual termination of the spine, is the representative in man of these occasionally well developed tails. All of us have potential tails. In early embryonic life of man there is a well developed tail which, however, soon shrivels, leaving only the coccyx.
It is a very significant fact that the anthropoid apes, gorilla, chimpanzee, etc., like man, have also lost their tails. The monkeys, much more distant from man, have retained their tails.
More damning, however, is a photograph he provided for the chapter with the caption: “Photograph of an Igorot in the Bontoc Province of the Philippine Islands. It was taken early in 1925 by Mr. John Freeman, (Dr. Keen’s grandson), whose guide and interpreter persuaded the man to be photographed. The tail is about five inches long. It also shows in the shadow.”
On April 2, 1926 (https://www.science.org/…/10.1126/science.63.1631.360.a), Keen embarrassingly admitted that the photo was a hoax.
“The correction I wish to make is as follows: In my book ‘I Believe in God and in Evolution,’ I have included in the fourth edition a photograph of an Igorot with a tail, which I vouched for as I understood that it had been photographed by my own grandson, Mr. John Freeman.
A few days ago within a few hours of each other, I received letters from Dr. Ales Hrdlieka, of the division of physical anthropology of the National Museum of the Smithsonian Institution, and Mrs. Ella F. Grove, who a year ago had been doing some work in the Philippines for the National Research Council. Both of these correspondents stated that the Bureau of Science in Manila had shown them the original of this photograph which showed that it was a fake photograph, the tail having been added to the original by a photographer, I suppose as a joke.
On communicating with my grandson I find that I misinterpreted his letter and that he did not photograph this Igorot.
My argument that human tails (of which I have shown there are very many undoubted instances) prove our animal ancestry is not in the least disproved by my having unfortunately used a photograph which further investigation has shown to be a fraud, for there are plenty of genuine tails.
My whole object is to state the truth, and when any statement I have made is proved to be wrong, I wish to be the very first person to disclose the error.”
Dr. Hrdlieka adds “As to the occurrence of tails of course I am with you in every particular.”
The correction must have been made but the joke remains up to now.
In 2017, celebrated Igorot blogger Dr. Kilimanguru still have to debunk the hoax.
https://www.wowcordillera.com/…/video-of-student-from…
Other young Igorots have to do the same.
https://greenmindedryan.wordpress.com/…/im-an-igorot…/ and https://opinion.inquirer.net/…/reminder-for-the-taga-baba
It may be a prank but the effect on the discrimination of Igorots is pervading. Which is why it is indeed important, in 1925 and now, to fact-check.
#FactsFirstPH
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

FACT CHECK: Fabled Yamashita gold is right under the new Bilibid prison which is why its suspended director Gen. Bantag dug a hole #FactsFirstPH

Next Post

FACT CHECK: Suspended Prison Chief Bantag was replaced and accused of the Lapid murder to give way for the release from prison of former Sen. Leila de Lima #FactsFirstPH

Baguio Chronicle

Baguio Chronicle

Hailed by the Philippine Press Institute’s Annual Community Press Awards for Excellence as the country’s Best Edited Community Newspaper. Best in Photo Journalism-Weekly 2015 & 2016 and Best in Environmental Reporting-Weekly in 2018.

Related Posts

FACT CHECK: BDO opens new money-making platform for Filipinos

FACT CHECK: BDO opens new money-making platform for Filipinos

August 30, 2023
FACT CHECK: PH has biggest deuterium reserves in the world, can be used to pay debts

FACT CHECK: PH has biggest deuterium reserves in the world, can be used to pay debts

August 29, 2023

FACT CHECK: Popular TV broadcaster Mike Enriquez died on August 29, 2023

FACT CHECK: Iran and the Philippines are forming an alliance against China #FactsFirstPH

FACT CHECK: Philippines has one of the lowest inflation rates in the world #FactsFirstPH

FACT CHECK: President Ferdinand ‘Bongbong’ Marcos Jr. did not get a special diploma from UA&P #FactsFirstPH

Latest Stories

Green Minded – Making eating out sustainable in Baguio City

Cat vs capitalism

May 31, 2025
BROKEN NATIVE – October is not a festival for IPs but a clarion call

Manual vote count at precinct level; goons go online

May 31, 2025
EDITORIAL – Our litmus test

EDITORIAL – Our litmus test

May 10, 2025

Baguio Chronicle

 

The Baguio Chronicle is the fastest- growing news publication in Northern Luzon today. It was established on December 6, 2009 in Baguio City.

© 2022 The Baguio Chronicle Website Design and Development by Neitiviti Studios.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    • NATION
    • CORDILLERA
  • BUSINESS
  • GREEN
  • OPINION
    • EDITORIAL
  • FEATURE
  • FACT CHECK
  • HEALTH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • LITERATURE
  • SPORTS
  • ADVERTORIALS
  • ABOUT US
    • CONTACT US